Let me be straight with you. This is one of those debates that sounds simple until you actually get into it, and then it turns out there are real nuances worth understanding before you drop money on an optic or double down on your irons.
So here’s my honest take, laid out clearly, with the one point where Paul and I genuinely disagree—surprise, surprise.
The Case for the Red Dot
The single biggest advantage of a red dot on a pistol is target-focused shooting. In a real defensive encounter, your eyes are going to lock onto the threat. You don’t even really have a choice in the matter. It is a hardwired physiological response.
Under stress, with adrenaline flooding your system, searching for a front sight you can’t see clearly because your focus is already on the threat in front of you is a well-documented occurrence. A red dot, however, lets you keep your eyes where they naturally want to be and still drop rounds on target.
This advantage compounds dramatically for aging eyes. If you’re over 40 and your close vision is starting to go, that crisp visual of the front sight becomes increasingly harder to find, but a red dot floating on top of your target does not.
I’ve watched shooters who struggled for years with irons find an entirely new level of confidence and accuracy once they made the switch. Don’t get me wrong, red dot optics aren’t a crutch. For the vast majority of people—probably even all—it’s the tool that actually rewards how our eyes work.
Follow-up shots are faster with a red dot. Target transitions are cleaner. At distance, the red dot gives you a level of precision that irons make significantly harder. Across almost every dimension of practical pistol shooting, the red dot performs better.
Is it the future? I’d argue it’s already the present. Everything I carry runs a red dot. There’s a reason the fastest divisions in competitive shooting are red dot divisions. They don’t compete against iron-sight shooters because the comparison isn’t fair.
The Cons Worth Knowing
The red dot is not without its drawbacks, and you should go in clear-eyed. Batteries die. Windows fog. Debris can obscure your sight picture. Every mechanical system has a failure mode, and a red dot has more of them than iron sights do.
That being said, I’ve seen iron sights fly off a gun under recoil. A quality optic mounted correctly minimizes these risks significantly, but they still exist.
One con to red dots that may be inescapable for some is astigmatism. Depending on the severity, I know people who have had great success choosing optics with a 1 MOA dot to reduce the amount of starburst or blooming they experience. But if you have an astigmatism, your mileage may vary.
If you’ve got it really bad, Trijicon does make an RMR with fiber-optic technology that you might find suitable.
Going back to my last point about correctly mounting your optic, improper installation is one of the most common mistakes on the range. Read the manual, torque it to specification with the correct screws and the correct Loctite, and mount it properly the first time.
A red dot that shifts zero because it wasn’t properly installed isn’t a red dot problem. It’s a user issue.
And here is where I’ll be honest about iron sights. For a screaming-fast first-round hit at close range, I am faster with irons. The red dot costs me about a tenth of a second in that singular draw-and-fire scenario.
Once it’s on target, though, the red dot never lets up. Think of it like a pit bull: slightly slower out of the gate, but once it latches on, it doesn’t quit. For the totality of a real shooting situation—target transitions, distance, and follow-up shots—the red dot takes it.
Where I Stand on New Shooters
Here’s where I’ll plant my flag, even knowing not everyone agrees with me:
If you’re new to shooting, start with iron sights.
Here’s why.
Learning to present a pistol correctly—driving that front sight up on target through a disciplined draw stroke—builds a foundation that transfers directly to the red dot. When you get good at finding your irons, the red dot is simply there when you transition.
The presentation is the skill. The sighting system is the tool on top of it.
What I see constantly on the range is new shooters slapping a red dot on a pistol before they’ve built that foundation. Then they’re hunting for the dot every single time they present the pistol.
They never find it because their presentation is inconsistent. When I coach those shooters to forget the dot and look for their front sight instead, the dot shows up right where it should every time.
Get your irons dialed in first. Build the presentation. Then add the red dot and watch it fall into place.
The Right Setup to Start and Grow
This is exactly why I partnered with Shadow Systems on our War Poet pistol. It gives you everything you need to build your skills with iron sights out of the box, and it’s set up to accept a red dot when you’re ready to make that transition.
It doesn’t accept just one type of red dot, either. It supports a wide range of optics due to Shadow Systems’ ingenious mounting solution. You can trust that the gun will work with nearly every pistol dot on the market.
You don’t have to buy twice. You build the foundation on the irons, and when the time is right, you upgrade without changing platforms.
When you’re ready to add an optic, I’ve put together a list of John-approved red dot sights at warriorpoetsociety.com.
These are the options I actually run and stand behind, selected for reliability, durability, and value at different price points.
The Bottom Line
Red dot or iron sights? Both have a place.
Iron sights build the foundation. Red dots unlock the ceiling.
If you’re new, learn your irons first and learn them well. If you’re an experienced shooter who hasn’t made the switch yet, the red dot is worth the investment and the training time it takes to run it correctly.
And if your eyes aren’t what they used to be, stop fighting it. The red dot exists for exactly that reason.
Just don’t skip the fundamentals to get there. The dot won’t fix a broken presentation. Nothing will except correct repetitions, good coaching, and the discipline to build the skill before you buy the gadget.
Remember: Train Hard. Train Smart.
Make sure your gear is serving your skills, not substituting for them.
Comments (22)
Excellent article, and IMO, spot on. I believe the same goes for red dots on sporting rifles as well. A friend that has no real background in firearms bought his first AR and immediately started shopping for a red dot. I asked why and he said because he read it’s easier to get on-target. I then asked him “So what happens if the red dot fails for some reason?”. He looked at me with a puzzled look and asked " what do you mean?". I had to explain to him 1) the rifle should be sighted in using the iron sights in the event you need to use them, and 2) if you don’t practice with the iron sights, then the rifle becomes way less effective if you do have an issue with the red dot. I came from old school where we didn’t have red dots, so all weapons quals (and combat) was done with iron sights. I was surprised to learn from one of my co-workers that while he had to qualify in basic training with iron sights, quals done in his unit were with red-dot. At this time, the only firearm I have a red dot on is my AR style shotgun for easier target area acquisition in low light. There’s too much reliance on technology these days (yes, I carry a GPS when out hiking/backpacking/hunting, but also always carry and rely on a actual map, compass, and my map reading/land nav skills I learned and honed as a 13F Fire Support Specialist).
I train a group of about 25 guys on our church security team. We train at the range 2x per month. Most have switched to read dots, but I have not. Sometimes our training is in the early morning or late evening when the sun is low. I’d like to point out a couple additional challenges I see. Guys with dots sometime struggle with the bright sun in front of them or behind them. Sometimes they see multiple “dots” due to the sunlight and have to pick one. I also see guys pull out their pistol and adjust their dot brightness. I often ask them if they plan to ask the bad guy to wait while they do that.
Love your stuff!
God Bless.
Leave a Comment